The Expat Retirement Timing Trap: Why “Later” Is Not a Neutral Decision

One of the most common phrases I hear from expats when retirement comes up is some version of “we’ll just do it a bit later”.

Later, when the portfolio is larger.

Later, when markets feel more settled.

Later, when life is less busy.

Later, when plans are clearer.

On the surface, that sounds sensible. Retirement is a major transition, and delaying it feels like a way to reduce risk rather than increase it. More time to grow assets, more time to earn, more time to prepare.

The problem is that “later” is rarely neutral.

For expats in particular, delaying retirement decisions often changes the shape of risk rather than reducing it, and it does so quietly, without any obvious trigger point that forces a rethink.

Why Expat Retirement Timing Is a Structural Decision, Not a Date on a Calendar

Most people think of retirement timing as a single moment. You stop working. Income switches on. Life changes.

In reality, retirement is a sequence of decisions that begins long before work actually stops. How long capital remains exposed to markets, when income begins to be drawn, which jurisdictions apply, and how assets are accessed all matter far more than the headline retirement age itself.

When retirement is delayed without active planning, those decisions tend to default rather than being chosen. Market exposure stays higher for longer. Tax assumptions remain untested. Withdrawal sequencing is left vague.

None of that feels risky while markets are calm and income is still flowing. It becomes risky when timing compresses and options narrow.

How “Later” Quietly Shrinks the Margin for Error

The biggest danger in delaying retirement planning is not that markets might fall tomorrow. It’s that the margin for error steadily shrinks while nothing appears to be changing.

When you are ten or fifteen years away from retirement, there is usually time to absorb poor returns, adjust contributions, or change course. When that window shortens, outcomes become far more sensitive to timing, valuation, and sequencing.

For expats, this sensitivity is amplified by factors that domestic investors rarely have to consider at the same scale. Residency may change. Tax treatment of income can shift dramatically. Access to certain structures or planning tools may disappear once a move is made or a status changes.

Delaying decisions does not freeze these variables. It allows them to evolve in the background while assumptions remain static.

The Sequencing Risk Most Expats Don’t See Coming

One of the least understood aspects of retirement timing is sequencing risk.

This is not about whether markets go up or down in the long run. It is about the order in which returns occur relative to when capital starts being accessed.

If poor or mediocre returns happen early in retirement, the impact on long-term sustainability can be severe, even if average returns over time look acceptable. This risk is far more pronounced when portfolios remain heavily growth-oriented right up to the point income is required.

Many expats assume that delaying retirement automatically reduces sequencing risk because it gives portfolios more time to grow. In reality, delaying often increases exposure to it by keeping portfolios fully invested through late-cycle conditions, while reducing the flexibility to adjust once income needs become real.

Why Expats Are Especially Vulnerable to Timing Compression

Timing compression happens when several decisions that were assumed to be spread out over years suddenly need to be made within a much shorter window.

An expat who delays retirement planning may find that returning to the UK, changing residency, accessing pensions, restructuring investments, and drawing income all collide within a narrow timeframe. Each decision affects the others, and the order in which they are taken can materially change outcomes.

This is rarely intentional. It happens because retirement is treated as a future event rather than an evolving process.

By the time the need for clarity becomes urgent, the flexibility that made “later” feel safe has often already gone.

Why Markets Make This Trap Harder to Recognise

Calm or steadily rising markets reinforce the idea that delaying is benign.

Portfolios look healthy. Projections appear achievable. The sense is that waiting simply allows compounding to do more of the heavy lifting.

What these conditions mask is the growing dependence on favourable outcomes continuing. When valuations are elevated and return expectations are implicitly anchored to recent history, delaying retirement planning increases reliance on assumptions that may not hold.

This is not a prediction about market crashes. It is an observation about expectation risk. If the next decade delivers lower or more uneven returns than the last, plans that relied on “one more good run” can unravel surprisingly quickly.

The Difference Between Choosing Later and Drifting Into It

There is nothing wrong with retiring later if it is a conscious, structured decision.

The problem arises when “later” is not chosen but defaulted into. When it becomes a placeholder rather than a plan.

A deliberate delay would involve adjusting portfolio risk as timelines shorten, stress-testing income sustainability under less favourable return scenarios, and understanding how tax and residency rules interact with withdrawal timing.

Drifting into delay involves none of this. It relies on hope, familiarity, and the absence of immediate pressure.

From the outside, both approaches can look identical for years. The difference only becomes visible once conditions change.

This timing trap often sits on top of other choices made earlier, particularly around portfolio simplicity and DIY investing.

As discussed in “Why Simpler Portfolios Can Create Bigger Problems for Expats”, portfolios that feel easy to manage can hide concentration and behavioural risk. When retirement is delayed, those same portfolios are often left untouched for longer than intended, thereby increasing exposure precisely when resilience matters most.

And as explored in “Expat Financial Decisions Are Increasingly Being Judged in Hindsight”, decisions that seemed independent at the time can later be assessed as a connected sequence. Retirement timing plays a major role in how that sequence is interpreted.

Why This Is Hard to Fix at the Last Minute

Retirement timing problems are rarely solved by a single adjustment.

Once income needs are imminent, changes tend to be larger, more disruptive, and more tax-sensitive. Risk reduction becomes reactive rather than strategic. Options that would have been straightforward years earlier are no longer available or are more costly.

This is why many expats feel blindsided by retirement planning challenges despite having done “everything right” along the way. The issue was not a lack of effort or discipline. It was timing.

A final thought

Retirement does not become safer simply because it is delayed. In many cases, it becomes more fragile, because assumptions harden while flexibility fades.

If your current plan assumes that you can decide later without consequence, it may be worth asking whether later is still working in your favour, or whether it is quietly compressing risk into a smaller and more sensitive window.

That question is difficult to answer from inside your own plan, especially when markets are calm and nothing feels urgent. It is far easier to explore while time is still on your side.

If you want to understand whether delaying retirement decisions is genuinely reducing risk, or simply reshaping it in ways you haven’t accounted for, that is usually best unpacked in a proper conversation rather than a projection spreadsheet.

Start with a conversation. Book a discovery call with My Intelligent Investor and get clear on where you stand, what’s changing, and what you can do about it. Let’s build a strategy that turns market complexity into opportunity.

Get in Touch Today:

📞 Call Us: 00971 (0) 58 579 4523

📧 Email Us: info@myintelligentinvestor.com

📅 Book a Meeting Directly: 

Discovery Call

45

Book Now

Looking for more insights? Check out our other insights for expert tips and advice that may be helpful.