When Markets Feel Calm But Aren’t: Why Expats Misread Investment Risk Late in the Cycle

One of the most dangerous moments in any financial cycle is rarely when markets are volatile or visibly stressed. Those periods attract attention naturally. They force decisions, prompt reviews, and make expat investment risk feel tangible.

The more difficult moments are the calm ones.

When markets appear orderly, headlines are quieter, portfolios look stable, and recent performance still feels supportive, planning often slips down the priority list. For many expats, this is the point where financial decisions feel least urgent, precisely because nothing appears to be going wrong.

That sense of calm is often where the real risk begins to build.

What makes this phase so challenging is that the danger is no longer obvious. Risk becomes slower, more structural, and far harder to recognise from inside your own plan, especially when recent experience continues to reinforce confidence.

Why Calm Markets Create a False Sense of Control

Most investors are conditioned to associate risk with noise. Sharp drawdowns, unsettling headlines, and visible volatility trigger attention because they feel threatening and demand action.

Calm markets do the opposite. They create the impression that things are under control, that the system is functioning as expected, and that there is plenty of time to revisit decisions later if circumstances change.

The issue is that markets do not reward or punish investors evenly across a full cycle. Risk tends to accumulate quietly during periods of stability, particularly when valuations are elevated, and expectations are anchored to what has just worked.

For expats, this effect is often amplified. Distance from home markets, demanding professional lives, and the absence of immediate tax pressure can make calm conditions appear to confirm that the plan is broadly sound. The assumption becomes that adjustments can always be made later, once markets become less favourable or a return date becomes clearer.

By the time that assumption is tested, the conditions that allowed flexibility are often already gone.

Expat Late-Cycle Investment Risk Rarely Looks Like a Crisis

Late-cycle risk does not announce itself with a single event or policy change. It emerges from stretched valuations, narrower sources of return, and a widening gap between what investors expect markets to deliver and what is realistically achievable going forward.

This is where many expats misread the environment, not because they are careless, but because they are extrapolating the wrong signals. Recent returns appear normal; therefore, future returns are assumed to follow a similar pattern. Market calm reinforces the belief that risk is low, even though the underlying drivers of that calm may be increasingly fragile.

The danger here is not short-term volatility. It is long-term disappointment combined with poor timing decisions around retirement, repatriation, or major lifestyle changes that depend on markets continuing to cooperate.

Why This Matters More for Expats Than for Domestic Investors

Expats typically operate with more moving parts than domestic investors. Residency status can change. Tax exposure can shift quickly. Income patterns are often uneven, particularly where bonuses or equity compensation are involved. Planning decisions are frequently deferred because the future location is not yet fully defined.

In calm market conditions, these complexities are easy to ignore. Portfolios appear to be doing their job, so deeper structural questions are pushed aside. The assumption is that planning can be revisited once markets become less favourable or when a move becomes imminent.

The problem is that late-cycle calm is often the worst time to delay those decisions. This is when assumptions become embedded, portfolios become more exposed to valuation risk, and optionality quietly narrows without any obvious warning signs.

Valuations and the Risk of Expectation Mismatch

One reason calm markets feel safe is that price movements alone do not capture risk particularly well. When valuations are already high, future returns become far more dependent on continued earnings growth and favourable conditions persisting.

Forward-looking valuation measures indicate that markets are not currently priced for optimistic outcomes over the next decade. Historically, when markets begin a period from elevated valuation levels, subsequent long-term returns tend to be flatter and more uneven than investors expect, even if there are strong years along the way.

This matters because many expats have built or simplified portfolios during a period where valuation expansion played a meaningful role in returns. When that tailwind fades, calm markets can still deliver outcomes that fall short of the expectations that shaped earlier decisions.

Risk, in this context, is not about drawdowns. It is about the gap between expected outcomes and realistic ones, and how that gap affects life decisions that depend on timing.

Why Calm Markets Delay the Right Conversations

One of the most consistent patterns I see is that calm markets encourage delay. When nothing feels broken, there is little emotional incentive to revisit assumptions, stress-test timelines, or question whether the structure of a plan still fits the reality ahead.

This is particularly true for financially capable expats and DIY investors who feel confident monitoring performance. Reviews tend to focus on what has happened rather than on how different future scenarios might affect outcomes once tax, residency, and timing are taken into account.

The result is that planning conversations often begin only once markets become uncomfortable. By that point, choices are already constrained by valuation levels, policy direction, or the simple fact that time has passed.

The Cost of Getting the Timing Wrong

Late-cycle misreads rarely lead to a single dramatic mistake. Instead, they tend to produce a series of small, individually reasonable decisions that quietly compound into a much bigger problem over time.

How Optimistic Assumptions Become Embedded

Retirement dates are often pencilled in using optimistic return assumptions drawn from recent market history or simple compound growth calculators, often without fully accounting for inflation, taxation, or the drag of drawing income from a portfolio. On paper, the numbers appear to work. In reality, the margin for error is far thinner than it looks.

When markets feel calm, those assumptions go largely unchallenged. Returns from the last cycle are a reasonable guide for the next, even though valuation starting points, tax conditions, and withdrawal needs may differ significantly.

Why Delay Feels Sensible, Until It Isn’t

Repatriation plans are being pushed back because portfolios have not yet reached the expected level. The assumption is that one more favourable year will close the gap, particularly when markets feel orderly, and valuations appear stable.

At the same time, risk exposure is often maintained longer than initially intended. Calm conditions reinforce the belief that adjustments can always be made later, once things are clearer or closer to the decision point.

The difficulty is that late in a cycle, clarity often arrives at the same time as constraint.

When Flexibility Quietly Disappears

When conditions finally do change, whether through market repricing, higher interest rates, tax drag, or shifts in residency and income, those adjustments become far harder to make without consequence.

What once felt like a flexible plan begins to feel rigid, not because the underlying goals were wrong, but because the sequencing was. Timing is compressed, and options that were previously available are no longer available in the same form.

This is the point at which many expats realise that planning assumptions were carrying more weight than expected.

Why Diversification Is Often Misunderstood at This Stage

This is where diversification and portfolio structure start to matter in a way that is often misunderstood.

Diversification is not simply about owning a range of assets. It is about ensuring that different parts of the portfolio behave differently as conditions change, and that risk can be reduced progressively without forcing poorly timed decisions.

Many DIY portfolios are diversified in name but not in outcome, particularly when passive, market-weighted exposure dominates, and valuation risk is concentrated in the same underlying drivers.

Aligning Portfolios With Reducing Risk Profiles

As investors move closer to key life decisions, whether that is retirement, a return to the UK, or a shift towards relying on portfolio income, the portfolio needs to evolve alongside those changes.

Risk profiles are not static. They reduce as optionality reduces.

A portfolio that was entirely appropriate when time felt abundant can become a liability when timing starts to matter. Adjusting holdings to reflect that shift requires more than simply selecting a lower-risk option on a questionnaire.

It involves understanding how assets interact with taxation, withdrawals, currency exposure, and future planning decisions, particularly in a cross-border context.

UK pensions are a prime example of this. Expats start contributing to them while in a different country and at a much younger age. Then, to leave them in their default investment strategy with little to no advisory oversight or alignment to the rest of your financial planning. Makes sense... right?

Where Experienced Planning Actually Adds Value

This is not about predicting market moves or calling turning points.

It is about recognising when the margin for error has already shrunk, even though markets still look orderly on the surface.

That recognition is where experienced planning adds the most value. Not by reacting to headlines, but by ensuring that diversification, risk exposure, and structure evolve in step with life decisions, rather than lagging behind them.

It is also why many expats realise they need deeper guidance only after the fact, at which point some of the most effective options are no longer available.

Why This Is Ultimately a Planning Problem

It’s essential to be clear about what this is not. This is not a call to abandon growth assets or to react defensively to every phase of the cycle.

The real issue is how calm conditions influence behaviour, expectations, and planning discipline, particularly for expats whose circumstances can change quickly.

Good planning is not about reacting to markets. It is about ensuring the plan still works if markets deliver merely average outcomes rather than exceptional ones, and about understanding how investment behaviour interacts with tax, residency, and timing decisions over time.

That is not something most people can reliably assess within their own plans, no matter how engaged or capable they are.

A final thought

The most costly financial planning mistakes are rarely made during moments of panic. They are made during periods of calm, when assumptions go unchallenged because nothing appears to demand attention.

If your financial plan depends on the next phase of markets looking broadly like the last, or if important decisions are being deferred because conditions feel stable, there is a strong chance that calm is being mistaken for safety.

The value of good advice in these moments is not in predicting what markets will do next. It is about helping you understand where your assumptions may already be overly optimistic, where flexibility is quietly narrowing, and where better decisions are still available if made early enough.

If you want to explore how your own plan holds up under less favourable conditions, that conversation is far easier to have now, while calm still gives you choices, than later, when markets or timing remove them for you.

Start with a conversation. Book a discovery call with My Intelligent Investor and get clear on where you stand, what’s changing, and what you can do about it. Let’s build a strategy that turns market complexity into opportunity.

Get in Touch Today:

📞 Call Us: 00971 (0) 58 579 4523

📧 Email Us: info@myintelligentinvestor.com

📅 Book a Meeting Directly: 

Discovery Call

45

Book Now

Looking for more insights? Check out our other insights for expert tips and advice that may be helpful.